[0903.0950] Absence of anti-correlations and of baryon acoustic oscillations in the galaxy correlation function from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR7

Authors:  Francesco Sylos Labini, Nikolay L. Vasilyev, Yurij V. Baryshev
Abstract:  One of the most striking features predicted by standard models of galaxy formation is the presence of anti-correlations in the matter distribution at large enough scales ($r>r_c$). Simple arguments show that the location of the length-scale $r_c$, marking the transition from positive to negative correlations, is the same for any class of objects as for the full matter distribution, i.e. it is invariant under biasing. Considering several main-galaxy and luminous-red-galaxy volume-limited samples of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7, we measure, with the standard methods, that the redshift-space galaxy two-point correlation function remains positive at scales $>250$ Mpc/h, while in the concordance LCDM it should be negative beyond $r_c\approx 120$ Mpc/h. However we show that the large scale behavior of $\xi(r)$ is affected by systematic volume-dependent effects which make the detection of correlations to be only an estimate of a lower limit of their amplitude, spatial extension and statistical errors. We also show that because of the same systematic effects, the scale signaling the real space counterpart of the baryon acoustic oscillations is located, if present at all, at scales larger than 250 Mpc/h. These results are challenging for any model of structure formation.
[PDF]  [PS]  [BibTex]  [Bookmark]

Discussion related to specific recent arXiv papers
Post Reply
Mark Wyman
Posts: 3
Joined: January 13 2009
Affiliation: Perimeter Institute

[0903.0950] Absence of anti-correlations and of baryon acou

Post by Mark Wyman » March 12 2009

These authors claim there is no evidence for BAO in the galaxy correlation functions they compute using the SDSS DR7. Is there some obvious reason why it would be missing from the way they calculate galaxy correlation functions?

Anze Slosar
Posts: 183
Joined: September 24 2004
Affiliation: Brookhaven National Laboratory

[0903.0950] Absence of anti-correlations and of baryon acou

Post by Anze Slosar » March 12 2009

If you look at fig. 3 of


the data is positive, but consistent with theory at distance 100-200 Mpc. The same is actually also true if you look at Labini et al figure 2, blue points. I am quite confident that Eisenstein knows what he's doing and the data haven't improved that much in the past 3 years...
I haven't read the paper, but I would be surprised they could measure xi at distances >200 Mpc/h with the errorbars they claim! Pink points on their fig2 have errorbars at 300 the same size as errrobars at 80...

Post Reply